Background As a scout, I am able to mark MB requirements as complete which, when all reqs are marked “complete” Scoutbook auto- completes the entire MB. Problem 1: MB shows up in a scout’s list as complete pre-maturely on scout’s profile page User Story : As a scout/parent/leader, the list of MB …

[image] ChristopherDesforges: Problem 1: MB shows up in a scout’s list as complete pre-maturely on scout’s profile page User Story : As a scout/parent/leader, the list of MB under my profile page “Advancement” section should only reflect “approved” MBs. This is working as designed. The Scou…

Following up on Problem 4 (before/after captures) [Screen Shot 2021-04-05 at 12.46.23 PM]

[image] ChristopherDesforges: When approving, the MBC cannot enter a later date than that which was recorded when the requirement was marked complete. It seems like Scoutbook is demonstrating a conflict between the official position that “Completed” means “ready for review” and the plain-lang…

The 4 steps of advancement and how they relate to Scoutbook checkmarks: A Scout learns something. Once learned they mark it ‘completed’ in Scoutbook A Scout is examined and signed off. That is ‘approved’ in Scoutbook. A Scout is reviewed (for MBs that is when the troop approves the badge) A Scou…

This discussion probably belongs in its own thread, so admins can feel free to relocate it if deemed appropriate. [image] WilliamNelson: he 4 steps of advancement and how they relate to Scoutbook checkmarks: A Scout learns something. Once learned they mark it ‘completed’ in Scoutbook A Scout …

What Bill has outlined is how the Advancement Team at a National Level wants it - so there is really nothing to discuss - it follows the GTA

OK. I guess I’ll quit beating the dead horse, then. :frowning_face:

I just approved a requirement for an MB for a Scout that was marked complete on Feb 1, 2021. As you can see from this screen shot, the completion date did not change. The first date is the completion date, the 2nd date is the date I approved the requirement and the 3rd date is the date a leader, S…

Bug Report: Multiple MB related issues stemming from “completed” MB requirements

Scoutbook Using Scoutbook & Scoutbook Plus

ChristopherDesforges April 5, 2021, 4:38pm 3

Following up on Problem 2:
When approving, the MBC cannot enter a later date than that which was recorded when the requirement was marked complete.

Topic		Replies	Views
Merit badge Items reported Complete by Scout, show up in Leader Approval report Using Scoutbook & Scoutbook Plus	28	3917	April 26, 2021
MB complete - But no notice to Advancement Chair Scoutbook & Scoutbook Plus Bugs	9	397	February 12, 2021
How to fix an incorrect approve/award of merit badge Using Scoutbook & Scoutbook Plus	44	220	September 22, 2025
How to prevent Scouts and Parents from updating Merit Badges Using Scoutbook & Scoutbook Plus	27	8290	May 19, 2020
Slightly Different Bug with BOR approval Life? Using Scoutbook & Scoutbook Plus	16	117	October 6, 2025

Bug Report: Multiple MB related issues stemming from “completed” MB requirements

Related topics