Report Builder shows the blue check for a scout, when it is only marked as completed in Scoutbook (my understanding is green check in Scoutbook is equivalent to blue square in Report Builder):

(Circled requirements are for the same scout)
@JamesMayled can you capture the url of the report so we can report to developers to investigate. Thanks.
@JamesMayled can you try and let us know if it is fixed? The developers have deployed an update.
It looks like the fix worked! Thanks!