MBC- "Youth information does not match any record"

Most of my active MBs ported over to SB+, but Citizenship in the Nation did not. When I tried to connect myself to the scouts so I can re-enter the badge requirements, I get an error saying the records do not match. However, I copied/pasted the last names and IDs directly from the roster. (The first picture is my own child, so I know 100% that ID is correct)

@CaraMarlowe the name search is Case sensetive